March 12, 2018

Stargate Origins: Episodes 8-10 and #StargateRising

Ra makes an appearance in the final episode of Stargate Origins.

We’ve reached the end of Stargate Origins, but it’s hardly a dour time for Stargate fans. There’s a sense of excitement in the fanbase that I haven’t seen in a long time. The TV landscape has changed dramatically since the final days of SGU in 2011; there are a lot more distribution options. Before I get too distracted, let’s dive back into Origins’ last three episodes.

I like the fact that MGM split up the 10 episodes into four weeks instead of dumping them all at once. That choice extended the interest from viewers across a full month, even if they disliked it. On the other hand, Origins probably works better as a feature than in 10-minute episodes. I’ll be curious to see if the events flow more seamlessly as a single narrative. If nothing else, it would remove the silly effect of spinning the camera at the end of each part. Let’s take a look at the last three episodes and how they finished the story.

Aset dons a new look to appear at the Abydonian outpost on Stargate Origins.

Episode 8: Testing Her Allies

The Abydonian outpost is the site for a family reunion of sorts, though Dr. Langford and Catherine don’t speak directly. She hides in the tent nearby with Beal while Aset tests her followers. Once again, a large group of characters stand in strangely close quarters while the camera zooms in with too many close-ups. We need to feel the scale of this place! I recognize the budget limitations, but it shouldn’t be so obvious. What should be a tense moment loses steam because it’s such a compact sequence.

On the positive side, I have to take a moment to rave about the costumes for Aset (especially) and Serqet. I think they spent half the show’s budget on these few outfits! They look amazing and over the top, which helps to make the Goa’uld look even more godlike to the tribe. The scenes involving Aset are frequently the best in the show because the stakes seem real. She also makes Origins feel like more than a low-rent adventure serial.

Less inspiring is the disintegration of Brücke, who saves his fellow Nazi Stefan and then shoots him. His descent into madness connects to humans from SG-1 that couldn’t handle a taste of Goa’uld power. Everything just seems too obvious, however. When Eva tells him that “you have no good side”, the point lands with a thud because it’s so on the nose. Connor Trinneer still brings emotion and grace to Dr. Langford, but it’s like he’s acting in a difference series.

Catherine Langford explores the desert with Kasuf in Stargate Origins.

Episode 9: Fresh Air

I can’t overstate the importance of stepping outside into the desert in this episode. Too many scenes happen in the same few rooms. It’s a relief when Catherine and her pals venture out and prepare to rescue her father. I also enjoyed the callback to the original Stargate film with the symbols inside the tunnel. There’s even an explanation for why Daniel Jackson couldn’t find the point of origin in that movie. It’s one of the cooler touches in this prequel series.

Another interesting moment has Aset questioning whether to kill Catherine or send her to the mines. Dr. Langford doesn’t translate that part of her statement to Brücke, which reminds us of the limitations of the Nazi’s influence. The final moment with Dr. Langford confronting Brücke feels well-earned mostly because Trinneer makes us care for the guy. We don’t want to see him meekly serve Aset and Brücke without taking a shot at freedom.

This episode also includes Origins’ best scene when Catherine tells Kasuf about the Goa’uld’s true nature. Her efforts don’t convince him, and Ellie Gall’s face makes the scene resonate. There’s real emotion in this scene, and it nearly makes up for her awkward communications with Kasuf at the start. This show needs greater stakes, and moments like this one sell the idea that we’re watching more than just a low-budget adventure story.

Aset prepares to act in the finale of Stargate Origins.

Episode 10: Tying Up the Loose Ends

The challenges of Origins’ short running time stand out during the final episode. Ra appears as the great continuity fixer to set the stage for the events in Stargate. Amnesia is the laziest way to fix inconsistencies, but that’s the road we take here. Making Catherine and Dr. Langford forget everything solves the issues but also feels like a cheat. The resolutions for Beal, Wasif, and Motawk arrive so quickly that it’s hard to even comprehend everything.

I did enjoy the idea that Aset planted the seed that led to Ra’s destruction in the future. It took many decades for it to happen, but Catherine eventually contacted Daniel to find Abydos once again. Turning Kasuf into a leader also feels random, but it helped to connect his character with Erick Avari’s older version from the movie and series. Ra moves the gate and kills nearly everyone without a second thought, but his doom will come down the road.

Beal was a frustrating character throughout much of this show; his complaining was set up for laughs yet never really hit home. He was just starting to get interesting in the past few episodes, which makes his death feel tragic. It’s quite a downer of a finale across the board; even the Harsesis child possibly died. We don’t see Aset or the baby perish, so it’s possible they survived for another season. That is also true for Beal, though his death seems more likely.

Another interesting part is Wasif finding love with Motawk, which had received hints in past episodes. I’m sure that some Stargate fans won’t love this story arc given their reactions to SGU. Even so, I appreciate any efforts to show a wider range of relationships on television. Seeing Wasif and Motawk conscripted by Ra as guards is a gut punch, though. They could return in a future season, but it’s hard to watch such a bleak resolution.

The Mission File on Stargate Command also includes a reference to Captain Mitchell, which connects this story to the events of Stargate: Continuum. I like the way that it bridges the two stories, but I would have enjoyed a slightly clearer reference on the show. There’s a risk in veering too far into fan service, but you don’t want to make Easter eggs so hard to find.

The Langfords stand in front of the Stargate at the end of Stargate Origins.

Origins: Some Final Words

It’s no coincidence that Joseph Mallozzi chose to begin the push for more Stargate right after Origins premiered. The fans are already engaged in the new show and have greater interest to push for a full series. The huge contrast in budget and scope between Origins and past Stargate series also reminds us of how great they were. If nothing else, this smaller show has brought fans back into the fold and convinced us that we want something better.

I don’t mean to keep criticizing Origins; making a prequel is not easy. When you also consider the miniscule budget, its chances of success were smaller. What bothers me is the time spent on worn-out tropes like Nazis, amnesia, and obvious colonialist topics. Why not cover similar territory but with interesting villains and a more nuanced resolution? Connor Trinneer did great work as Dr. Langford, and his steady presence stood out against the hammy Nazis.

You don’t need a giant budget to make an interesting Stargate series. Two of my favorite episodes from SG-1 are “Abyss” and “Threads”, and both mine great drama from long conversations. Origins can be fun yet still grab us without resorting to obvious story beats.

There’s so much potential in a show set in the ‘30s involving the Stargate. Parts of Origins nearly hit the mark but then got too safe. Did we really need the Nazis at all? Removing them would give Aset and Serqet more time to grow as characters and set up a more exciting main conflict. This is one example of many thoughts that I had as I watched Origins.

The city rises in the premiere of Stargate Atlantis.

The Success of #StargateRising

On Friday and Saturday, Stargate fans and a lot of familiar faces made their presence felt during a tweetstorm that spanned the globe. I participated on Friday and likely earned a few mutes on Twitter with many posts and retweets for #StargateRising. Some of our favorite actors like Amanda Tapping, Jewel Staite, David Hewlett, Brian J. Smith, Michael Shanks, and so many others joined the fun. It was heart-warming to have so many people that love the franchise coming together to push for more.

Beyond the energy of seeing the unified front, I’m hopeful that we have a chance for a real show. I love the idea of pushing for Robert C. Cooper and Brad Wright to return and continue the story. There’s endless potential even if some actors can’t appear due to other commitments. I have a feeling that we’re in store for a lot more great things from Stargate in the next few years. Is it possible that our journey is just beginning?

Related Articles

March 5, 2018

Stargate Origins: Episodes 6 & 7 and the Stargate Tweetstorm

Aset reveals her powers to the Nazis in Stargate Origins.

We’re an hour into Stargate Origins, and it feels both too short and strangely long. We don’t have enough time to really dive into the story, but scenes tend to extend beyond what’s needed. This is especially true when the Nazis appear; it’s hard to invest too much into their story. Other moments inch towards becoming interesting and have potential if they offered a bit more depth. That isn’t true with Brücke and his band of goofy villains.

The biggest hurdle for Director Mercedes Bryce Morgan and the writers is the small budget. It’s easy to criticize the limited sets and less effective CGI in Origins. I don’t mind an indie version of Stargate, but it’s harder to overlook the basic shots. In particular, the room with Dr. Langford and the imprisoned Nazis is quite dull. The camera sits back and gives us a medium shot that only exacerbates the limited sets. There are ways to reveal the horror of what Aset could accomplish with Hitler’s army. Instead, we remain at a distance from the events on screen.

It feels like we’re just playing out the string with Origins, but there’s still great excitement for the franchise. Building on the #StargateNow movement that I discussed last week, Joseph Mallozzi is rounding up the troops for an event to prove there’s still life in the fan base. Before I dive into that exciting day, let’s take a closer look at last week’s two Origins episodes.

The Nazi Brucke makes his move on Stargate Origins.

Episode 6: Showing Their Hand

Beginning with a close-up of a film camera, Episode 6 contains a lot of exposition. Aset needs allies (or slaves), and Brücke is willing to provide them. While Dr. Langford stews, the Nazis give Aset the perfect opportunity to gain power on Earth. Like I mentioned above, the shots are so flat here. It’s claustrophobic but not in a way that induces fear of a dangerous villain. The scene just sits there, and not even a clever jump cut between Dr. Langford and Catherine both wiping their brow can save it.

There’s more energy to Catherine’s scenes with the Abydonians, but it’s lessened with bickering. It’s hard to care much for Beal, who keeps disregarding Catherine’s justifiable concerns for her dad. The show also makes Kasuf appear dumb, which adds to the standard colonialist narrative. It’s designed for laughs, but it’s mostly just cringe-inducing. When the Seal of Ra switches to a Nazi symbol, it’s also less effective because of the earlier jump cut of wiping the brow.

I don’t mean to be too harsh about Origins. There are interesting conflicts lurking beneath the surface, and the idea of a Goa’uld working with Hitler has a lot of potential. I also loved the close-up of Aset holding the machine gun in front of the screen. It’s the best shot of the series thus far and sells her as a cool enemy. More of this in the future, please.

The Nazis and Dr. Langford wait for Aset's prize.

Episode 7: The Power of Naquadah

I’m intrigued by this episode’s opening scene where Aset displays the power of even the small rock that she presents to Brücke. Naquadah is no joke and powers all of the Goa’uld’s key weapons. Despite the over-the-top acting from Aylam Orian as Brücke, this scene feels like it belongs in a Stargate show. There’s a power-hungry Goa’uld enticing a less sophisticated human with the chance to dominate his world. It’s a cool opening but only lasts for a short time.

Back at the outpost, we’ve reached the next stage of the typical colonialist story. Seeing the necklace with Ra’s symbols, the natives assume that Catherine and her companions are important emissaries of the powerful being. We also have the weird native food and a drug that the humans fail to understand. This drug brings Catherine and Beal closer together despite her awful behavior. Their kiss at the end feels unfortunate because he’s just not a nice person at all.

The most interesting part of this episode appears in the Mission File on the Stargate Command website. That article clarifies that Aset is actually a clone of Isis, which solves one of the continuity issues spotted by fans. The problem is that we don’t learn this information in the actual episode. The theater show gives hints at the Ra/Aset relationship, but it’s a simpler picture than the reality. I hope we learn more in future episodes on Aset’s back story, but time is growing short.

Aset is a formidable Goa'uld in Stargate Origins.

March 9, 2018: Stargate Will Rise Again!

Let’s get to the real fun this week. If you want to see another Stargate TV series with a real budget and full episodes, set your calendars for March 9 at 9 p.m. Eastern Time. International fans should mark down March 10 at 7 p.m. GMT. Both slots will involve a one-hour tweetstorm that will help to reveal our Stargate dedication to MGM. Mallozzi explains the event in his February 26 blog post.

If you haven’t done so already, you should follow @Stargatenow on Twitter so you’re ready for the big event. They’ll reveal the hashtag 15 minutes before the tweetstorm; we should only use this one hastag to maximize trending for the topic. I know it seems a little silly to expect much from this event, but we’ve seen other examples of fan causes succeeding. Mallozzi believes that MGM wants to restart the franchise, so anything we can do to encourage them is essential. Let’s take this project to the next level!

Kasuf has some fun on Stargate Origins on Abydos.

Related Articles

Don't miss a post! Sign up to get new blog posts via e-mail.

February 23, 2018

Stargate Origins: Episodes 4 & 5 and #StargateNow

Catherine, Beal, and Wasif arrive via the Stargate in Abydos.

We’re now halfway through the 10 episodes of Stargate Origins, so the structure is a lot clearer. All of the main characters (beyond one dim-witted Nazi) are on Abydos in various states of danger. We’ve met the two Goa’uld characters, Aset and Serqet, who are generally more interesting than the flimsy heroes. The Nazis and Dr. Langford remain captured by Aset and can only wait for the next steps. They’ll need Catherine and her pals to step up and save the day. The stage is set for the big conflict between the various parties, but our time is short.

Only about 50 minutes remain in the entire show, and you can only accomplish so much in 10-minute episodes. Despite some fun moments, the limitations on money and time make it hard for Origins to really thrive. A lot has changed since I wrote about the first three episodes, however. Longtime Stargate writer and producer Joseph Mallozzi has initiated the quest for a new full series to extend the franchise. His presence has rejuvenated the fan base and made Origins’ success seem less essential for its future. Before diving into those efforts, let’s take a quick look at the two new episodes, which premiered yesterday at Stargate Command.

The Goa'uld warrior Serqet attacks Catherine Langford and her friends.

Episode 4: A Formidable Enemy

I love a good sci-fi adventure, and the classic premise of discovering an unknown world via the Stargate can work brilliantly. It’s a relief when Catherine, Beal, and Wasif leave the main structure and venture into the desert. That moment happens in Episode 5, however. They first battle with the Goa’uld warrior Serqet and have little chance against her. She’s played by Michelle Jubilee Gonzalez, whose career includes a lot of stunt work in TV and movies. Gonzalez is an imposing enemy, though the fight isn’t very thrilling.

I did enjoy seeing Serqet’s different type of staff weapon that worked for hand-to-hand combat. The large hook at the end makes for an effective tool in close fights. It’s cool to see a little action on Origins, but this scene feels a bit awkward. The staging appears off, and the room’s tight quarters make for a limited fight. The appearance of the transportation rings is an exciting callback, especially to the movie and early SG-1 seasons.

Before encountering Serqet, the confused trio exits the Stargate and arrives on Abydos. I like the small touch of the ice on Catherine’s face, which is a callback to the early days. Less exciting is the over-the-top reaction from Beal, who’s just a painful character. He veers between obnoxious and cheesy behavior, and I don’t see any chemistry between him and Catherine. Beal is mostly around to set up Catherine as the stronger character. Exchanges like this are a good example:

Beal: “Stay put.
Catherine: “You wish!

While her reply made me chuckle, it’s hard to care much about Beal. Yelling “Boo!” at the Abydonian tribe member they discover is such a jerk move. Ellie also slaps him when he suggests that Dr. Langford is dead, and it’s well-deserved for a lot of reasons. Wasif mostly seems like an afterthought to the pair, despite his cool discovery of the world outside. The attractive shot of the three moons and the dunes mostly sells the off-world location. I can’t wait to get a chance to explore a little bit of this outside world.

The Goa'uld Aset has devious plans in Stargate Origins.

Episode 5: Aset’s Plans

While Episode 4 mostly involves the fight with Serqet, its follow-up involves all the characters in some fashion. We check in with the Nazis, Goa’uld, and Catherine’s group within a packed 10-minute story. It seems fitting to have so much as we reach Origins’ midpoint. The most interesting part of Episode 5 is the conversation between Aset and Serqet. There’s a revelation that the baby is a harsesis, which is the show’s first big surprise. We learned on SG-1 (particularly in season four's “Absolute Power”) that this child of two Goa’uld is extremely powerful. While it’s unclear who the father is right now, Ra is a possible candidate.

We also learn that Aset plans to use the humans to ferment a revolution against Ra. I’m not sure how this can go well, but it presents her more as an opportunist than a generic enemy. The idea of Aset using the Nazis for her own devious plans intrigues me. We also learn of her mysterious resurrection, which might help to explain fans’ continuity questions. There’s a lot of plot to uncover in limited time, so I’m unsure how much we’ll learn down the road.

Less inspiring is the scene with the Nazis, who remain weird caricatures. My reaction is similar to Dr. Langford, who’s just over the entire situation. His only solace is that Catherine is back on Earth, and a split-screen shot reminds us of how wrong he is. She’s busy having a painful conversation with Kasuf (Daniel Rashid), the Abydonian tribe member. Catherine’s attempts to teach Kasuf her name feel straight out of an old colonial narrative. Her frustrating approach treats him as dumb simply because Kasuf doesn’t understand English. It’s bad news.

Kasuf is a familiar name to Stargate fans; an older version of him encounters O’Neill and Jackson on Abydos in their first trip. Erick Avari played Kasuf in both the movie and SG-1, but that character seemed unfamiliar with Earth in that film. It will be interesting to see how that is presented in upcoming episodes, if it’s addressed at all. His character is mostly around to draw comedy out of their cultural differences, and those jokes fall flat.

On a positive note, Wasif’s stabbing by a frightened tribe member is a shock. Seeing all that blood (and a possibly mortal wound) brings weight to a show that has felt very light so far. I did not expect Wasif to die, and the quick resolution with the Wand of Horus ends any speculation. Even so, it’s refreshing to bring actual stakes to this story. The battle with Serqet included limited tension despite her skills. The stabbing is the first moment that convincingly sells the danger of going through the Stargate, and I hope to see more in the future.

The creepy face of the warrior Goa'uld Serqet in Stargate Origins.


The most exciting news of the week was Mallozzi’s surprise announcement of a strategy to strongly encourage MGM to revive Stargate completely. In a blog post titled “Stargate – the next step!”, Mallozzi outlines his feelings about the future of the franchise. He clarifies that a reboot or remake won’t serve the best needs of fans or the series. We’ve seen the challenges in Origins with shoehorning a story into Stargate’s past. Mallozzi pitches the idea of going back to the guys that helmed the ship for many years – Brad Wright and Robert C. Cooper.

What I love about the idea is how much it makes sense and isn’t just a pipe dream. It also unites the fans with a single objective – support the creation of a new series that continues the ongoing story. The possibilities for this show are endless; it could involve beloved characters from all three series plus new roles that expand the storytelling universe. I’d love to see more of Stargate Universe (SGU), but why stop there? You could explain what happened to The Destiny and involve Atlantis, Earth, and more all within a single package. Why not build on past success instead of recreating it?

If you’re a fan of any part of the Stargate world and want to help this cause, your first task is easy. Follow @StargateNow on Twitter and tweet out support with hashtags like #StargateNow and #DrivetoRevive. I’d also suggest following Mallozzi @barondestructo; he posts regular updates about the project. If you aren’t on Twitter, there’s also a Facebook page open for Stargate Now. This is just the beginning of the initiative, but the response has already been so positive. Fans may disagree on SGU or Origins, but few can argue with the push for a full Stargate rebirth. Let’s make this happen!

Related Articles

Reopening the Gate on Stargate Origins
The Reconsidering Stargate Universe Series
Stargate Universe: The Complete Final Season
Stargate SG-1’s Moebius: The True Series Finale
Stargate SG-1: Children of the Gods

Don't miss a post! Sign up to get new blog posts via e-mail.